Skip to Main Content
The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine
Board on Science Education
Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education
 Successful Out-of-School Learning: A Consensus Study
 Statement of Work

Recent national reports from the NRC, and others have highlighted ways that informal and afterschool STEM learning can support major student outcomes in STEM education. Connections to informal and afterschool offer an opportunity to extend learning beyond the classroom and school day by leveraging community supports such as afterschool and informal experiences, home environments and opportunities to encounter STEM that reside in a student’s geographic, physical, social, and (new) media environment. The NRC’s A Framework for K-12 Science Education as a blueprint for developing the Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) has pointed to a broader set of science outcomes for K-12 students, and two recent NRC reports on successful K-12 STEM practices have also embraced a broader perspective on STEM outcomes and STEM practices that will require a coordinated effort across the many contexts for STEM learning.

The Board on Science Education has assembled a 13 person expert committee to develop a concise primer on successful out-of-school STEM learning based on evidence of successful practice, and informed by a 2-day public workshop that explores the current evidence. The primer on best practices in out of school STEM learning will be written for policy-makers, funders, non-profit and private industry representatives, and other representatives from civic society. The primary goal of the report is to help these audiences better understand and more strategically support investments in informal and afterschool STEM education, and to encourage partnerships that promote the linking of out-of-school STEM learning to classroom- or school-based learning.

The committee on Out-of-School STEM Learning will specifically:
  • determine initial criteria for nominating successful practices to be considered at the workshop. The examples included in the workshop must be studied in enough detail to provide evidence to support claims of success.
  • identify highly successful practices in the area of STEM education in out-of-school settings, with a focus on designed settings and programs targeted at children and youth, through examination of a select set of examples.
  • initiate workshop discussions will focused on refining criteria for success, exploring models of “best practice,” and an analysis of factors that evidence indicates lead to success.
  • synthesize workshop discussions and a literature review of peer-reviewed and grey-literature publications for a short, committee-authored consensus report that outlines criteria for identifying effective out-of-school STEM settings and programs and identify those criteria for which data are readily available and those where further work is needed to develop appropriate data sources.
The committee’s report will be accompanied by major stakeholder engagement efforts conducted by the NRC, and in close collaboration with other stakeholders.

Sponsor: National Science Foundation

Information from the committee's workshop

During the course of the project, the committee held a workshop to identify the impacts of informal and afterschool STEM learning experiences and to explore how school and out-of-school environments can build upon and support one another.

The workshop included presentations on and discussions of:

  • Highly successful practices in out-of-school STEM education settings, with a focus on designed settings and programs targeted to children and youth.
  • Criteria for success, models of “best practices,” and factors that have been demonstrated to lead to success.
  • How to work with and support children and youth from underrepresented and underserved groups.
  • How to create a positive interplay between school and out-of-school STEM learning experiences.

► Agenda

► PowerPoint Presentations

► Presented Posters

► Briefing Materials

► Participant List

► Archived Webcast Videos


Commissioned Papers

Formative Assessment for STEM Learning Ecosystems: Biographical approaches as a resource for research and practice by Brigid Barron

Citizen Science and Youth Education by Rick Bonney, Tina B. Phillips, Jody Enck, Jennifer Shirk, and Nancy Trautmann

Evidence & Impact: Museum-Managed STEM Programs in Out-of-School Settings, by Bernadette Chi, Rena Dorph & Leah Reisman

Children Doing Science: Essential Idiosyncrasy and the Challenges of Assessment by David Hammer and Jennifer Radoff

Broadening Access to STEM Learning through Out-of-School Learning Environments by Laura Huerta Migus

Making and Tinkering: A Review of the Literature, by Shirin Vossoughi and Bronwyn Bevan

Committee Members

Eric Jolly (Chair), Science Museum of Minnesota
Bronwyn Bevan, San Francisco Exploratorium
Jane Buikstra, Arizona State University
Jacquelynne Eccles, University of California, Irvine
John Falk, Oregon State University
Maya Garcia, Government of the District of Columbia
Leslie Goodyear, Principal Research Scientist, EDC
Lynn Liben, Pennsylvania State University
Milbrey McLaughlin, Stanford University
Vera Michalchik, SRI International
Nancy Peter, University of Pennsylvania
Cary Sneider, Portland State University
Jill Walshoski, University of Nebraska



Home BOHSI Home BOSE Home BECS Home BCYF Home TAC Home Home BOTA Home CPOP Home CNSTAT Home CLAJ Home BBCSS Home Home About BOSE BOSE Mission BOSE Members BOSE Staff Our Sponsors Visiting our Buildings About BBCSS BBCSS History BBCSS Members BBCSS Staff Our Sponsors About CPOP CPOP Mission CPOP Members CPOP Staff About CNSTAT CNSTAT Members CNSTAT Staff CNSTAT Mission Other Sites of Interest TEstTAc2 About CLAJ CLAJ Mission CLAJ Members CLAJ Staff About BECS BECS Mission/History BECS Brochure BECS Members BECS Staff About BOHSI BOHSI History BOHSI Members BOHSI Staff Our Sponsors About BCYF BCYF History BCYF Graphic Illustration BCYF Members BCYF Staff Forum Home About Us Mission and Goals History Members Sponsors About BOTA BOTA Mission BOTA Members Visiting Our Buildings
left imagetext captioncenter image