Cycle 4 (2015 Deadline)
DNA barcoding to combat wildlife crime
PI: Henry Ndithia (firstname.lastname@example.org), National Museums of Kenya
U.S. Partner: David Schindel, Smithsonian Institution
Project Dates: October 2015 - September 2018
Wildlife criminals, poachers, and traffickers of endangered species protected under CITES and national laws are developing new ways to avoid detection and prosecution. In the case of protected animals, traffickers are shipping them as butchered and processed meat, eggs or juvenile stages, dried powders, and other forms that have proven difficult to identify. In these forms, even taxonomic experts cannot provide species identifications based on morphology because diagnostic characteristics (commonly provided by bones and hides) are absent from confiscated material. As a result, border inspectors, police, and park rangers may not suspect that intercepted objects come from protected species. Even in cases where suspicions are aroused and the materials are confiscated, crime investigators aren’t able to identify them with confidence. The same may prove true even for the expert zoologists who receive the objects for identification. In those rare cases when an expert provides an identification using the few morphological features preserved, it is difficult to overcome the objections of defense attorneys who raise doubts in the minds of magistrates.
This project proposes to use “DNA barcode” sequence data to identify confiscated materials by their species of origin. DNA barcoding has become an accepted and commonly used method for species identification practiced by taxonomists, ecologists and other academic researchers. Since 2012, Kenya has been one of six partner countries in the Google-supported Barcode of Wildlife Project (BWP), which has provided training to staff at the National Museums of Kenya and the Kenya Wildlife Service. These institutions are assembling a reference library of DNA barcodes from endangered species that can be used to identify confiscated material. The Kenyan researchers continue to receive technical support and advanced training from the Smithsonian Institution in Washington, the U.S. Government-supported partner on this project.
The two main objectives of the project are to expand training and technical assistance to new participants in Tanzania, as well as strengthen Kenya’s systemic response to poaching in two ways. First, DNA-based research on endangered species through the National Museums of Kenya will create new tools for prosecuting wildlife criminals. Second, collaboration with the Kenya Wildlife Service will put these tools to work in Kenyan courtrooms. The result should be a rapid near-term rise in the rate of convictions for poaching and trafficking, followed by long-term growth in the population sizes of endangered species and measures of ecosystem health. These should translate into prosperity in agriculture, greater food security, job creation, and a strong and sustainable tourism industry.
Summary of Recent Activities
In the second year of the project, a total of 4000 Fluid X tubes were donated by Phoenix and delivered to the National Museums of Kenya. The team has already started transferring the samples that were initially in vials into the fluid X tubes to await further analysis. This will make the collection and archival of any samples easier and more efficient, and will also contribute to good and reliable results being generated in the long run. Analysis of tissue samples is ongoing as well as DNA extraction. The analysis is being done to generate barcodes. The PI and his team have also been updating their Field Information Management System (FIMS) on a rolling basis as they get more samples for processing.
In Tanzania, about 47 tissue samples from various wildlife animal species previously collected from Arusha National Park, Wami Mbiki Game Reserve, Serengeti National park, Ngorongoro conservation Authority and Mikumi National Park were used to prepare the first FIMS report which was used during the DNA barcode training. This activity is ongoing and is scheduled to include more samples previously collected in other areas.
DNA barcoding and bioinformatics training course was held at the College of the Veterinary and Medical Sciences (CVMS) Molecular Biology laboratory, Sokoine University of Agriculture (SUA), Morogoro Tanzania this past quarter. A total of 12 trainees were selected from SUA (6), Tanzania Wildlife Research institute (TAWIRI) (3), Tanzania National Parks (TANAPA) (2), and Ngorongoro Conservation Area Authority (1). Three trainers came from Kenya and included Ann Mwaura (NMK), Antoinette Aluoch (KWS) and Ruth Mumo. A total of 118 applicants, coming from Tanzania, Kenya, Uganda and the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), had applied for this training.
There is continued collaboration between National Museums of Kenya, Kenya Wildlife Services (KWS) and the Tanzania Wildlife Research Institute (TAWIRI) under the ministry of Natural Resources. KWS and TAWIRI are the leading institutions in the prosecution of cases relating to wildlife crime in Kenya and Tanzania respectively. The Tanzanian team had a recent visitation at SUA of the Chief of party Ms Jennifer Talbot and John Ngowi of USAID-PROTECT Project, who are looking into providing funding support for the establishment of Wildlife Molecular Forensic capacity at SUA.
The co-PI in Tanzania, Dr. Mutayoba’s research permit was approved by the Research Program Committee (RPC) of TAWIRI) in June. This was immediately followed up by making new applications to Tanzania National Parks (TANAPA) and Ministry of Natural Resources and Tourism (MNRT) via Tanzania Wildlife Management Authority (TAWA) to enable the Tanzanian partners to gain entry to respective target National Parks (under TANAPA) and Game Reserves (under TAWA). These approvals will enable the team in Tanzania to continue with field work which has been delayed.
The laboratory work on DNA barcoding is currently actively ongoing but only for Sokoine University of Agriculture (SUA) technologists who attended the DNA barcoding course. The Tanzanian team is still looking into the logistics of bringing back on board the 6 trainees from the wildlife Sector due to their work logistics, most of them are field based, with poor internet and molecular lab access to enable them provide them the required supplies for doing DNA extraction and PCR amplifications at their localities. The option available is to let each one come back to SUA when appropriate but this will have huge financial implication on the project for supporting their subsistence until they can qualify for proficiency test. The current target is to have at least 4 SUA technologists apply for proficiency test before the end of September, 2017 to enable them start generate and submit the barcodes to the GenBank.
In August 2017, the lab has recruited two female graduates namely Mpete Herbertha and Mwajuma James who have now completed BSc degree in Laboratory Science and Biotechnology on a volunteer basis so as provide them with hands-on exposure on the routine ongoing activities in the lab. During the same month, six (6) female students have been accepted to undertake a Diploma in Laboratory Technology to volunteer for one month during the ongoing vacations at the University
The main aim was to introduce them to basic molecular biology techniques and management of such labs. These students completed the training in August, 2017.
Back to PEER Cycle 4 Grant Recipients